Skip to content

Cory Paternoster of The Upside: Why Great Music Doesn’t Have to Be Perfect

Tone Tailors Podcast   |   November 19, 2026

posted by: Olive



Youtube Spotify Apple Podcasts



Who is Cory Paternoster? Cory Paternoster is a Lancaster, Pennsylvania musician, recording engineer, drum teacher, and co-founder of The Upside, a recording and rehearsal space built for local musicians. This week, the Tone Tailors Podcast visited Cory at The Upside to talk about music lessons, making records, playing in bands, and why the best recording isn’t always the most perfect one.

Our full recording studio tour of The Upside covers the rooms and gear. This interview goes deeper into Cory’s music, business, and recording philosophy.

Cory Paternoster: A Childhood Dream of Playing in a Rock Band

Cory can trace his love of music back to elementary school. During an assignment that asked students to write down a wish, his was simple: he wanted to be in a rock band. The details of what that might look like came later, but the goal stuck.

Drum teacher Jim Love helped Cory see that a music career could involve teaching, playing shows, and recording. Cory later studied music recording and performance at Lebanon Valley College, where he met musicians he still plays with today.

How Drum Lessons Turned Into The Upside

Before The Upside existed, Cory was giving drum lessons at Lancaster’s Drums Etc. He loved teaching, but managing a store schedule while gigging and recording meant he needed more control over his time. He eventually began managing his own lesson schedule, which opened the door to something bigger.

Cory and fellow instructor Brian Doherty needed a place for teaching and rehearsal. They found a rough, affordable space in Lancaster and started making it their own. That meant building walls, clearing out old gear, and learning how to fix things as they went. Over time, the team, which also includes Nathan Williams, expanded into more rooms for recording, music lessons, and band rehearsals.

The Upside grew from real musicians’ needs. It still feels collaborative, with shared equipment and rooms where artists can get comfortable and create.

Why the Best Recording Isn’t Always the Perfect Recording

One of Cory’s biggest recording philosophies is that a take should feel right, not just look clean on a computer screen. Musicians can spend hours fixing tiny mistakes and still lose the energy that made them love a song in the first place.

His favorite example involves a guitar amp that started breaking up in a strange, increasingly awesome way during a demo. Then the amp stopped working. When it came time to record the finished song, they couldn’t recreate that exact tone, so they used the original demo guitar part instead. Sometimes the accidental take is the one you were looking for all along.

Cory still fixes weak sections when they need fixing. The trick is knowing which imperfections add character and which get in the way.

Do Bands Need a Click Track to Record Together?

Not always. Cory encourages musicians to learn timing and understand a metronome, but he doesn’t think a click track should make an entire band miserable. Some players are at their best when they’re watching each other and reacting naturally, just like they do at rehearsal or onstage.

He describes setting up a band in the recording room exactly where the players normally stand. There was some microphone bleed and less isolation than a conventional session, but the musicians were comfortable. Cory adjusted the microphones and baffles around their performance. That’s the advantage of recording with an engineer who knows how to adapt a room to the band.

A click is still useful for tight edits and overdubs. Talk with your engineer, rehearse your arrangements, and make sure your guitar is in good playing shape before your session.

The Best Studio Microphone Might Be the One You Already Have

Cory talks gear with us, of course. Some of the microphones that get regular use at The Upside include the Sennheiser MD 421 and Shure SM57 for instruments, along with an AKG C414 and vintage RCA ribbon microphones for other sounds. But his bigger point is that mic placement often matters more than the price tag.

Move a microphone a few inches across a guitar speaker and you can change the character of the entire part. Adjust its angle over a drum, or its distance from a singer, and the result changes again. Cory would rather experiment with placement before assuming another piece of equipment will solve the problem.

Before buying another mic, experiment. For ideas, read Shure’s microphone guide and our Spencer Studios podcast feature.

Making a Living in Lancaster Music Takes More Than One Gig

Cory isn’t only a producer or only a drum teacher. He’s a working musician with several different things going on. He teaches students, books recording sessions, helps manage The Upside, rehearses, records his own music, and plays live. That mix is part of how he’s built a sustainable creative life.

We also talk about local concerts. Cory misses the energy of The Upside’s former DIY shows, although recording and rehearsals are the focus now. He wants tickets to remain accessible without musicians undervaluing their work.

Cory’s Bands and a New Album From Whose Hands Are These?

Cory performs with Whose Hands Are These?, Sun Not Yellow, and Northern Gloom, and he also talks about local honky-tonk and jazz gigs. His music covers a lot of ground, which helps explain why he’s comfortable working with artists who have very different approaches.

Whose Hands Are These? released A Museum of Everything You’ve Ever Loved on November 4, 2026. Cory recorded the album at The Upside, but he brought in Ian Schiela to handle tracking, with Jon Smith mixing at The Kaleidoscope and James Trevascus mastering. He wanted the freedom to focus on playing rather than being the engineer for every minute of his own band’s record.

You don’t always have to do everything yourself. Another set of ears can help. Hear more of Cory’s drumming with Sun Not Yellow.

AI, Auto-Tune, and What Makes Music Human

Near the end, our conversation turns toward AI-generated music and pitch correction. Cory is protective of the human side of recording, including those happy accidents that make a song feel like it came from real people. He acknowledges that technology can be useful, but doesn’t want it replacing the choices and emotion of musicians making their own music.

Some vocals benefit from tuning; others lose their intimacy when corrected. His rule is simple: use a tool when it helps the song, not just because it’s available.

Quick Questions About Cory Paternoster and The Upside

What is The Upside in Lancaster, PA?

The Upside is a collaborative recording studio, music lesson facility, and rehearsal space in Lancaster City, Pennsylvania.

Does The Upside record bands playing live together?

Yes. Cory discusses recording full bands together and adapting the room to their playing style, including working without a click track when it fits the music.

What bands is Cory Paternoster in?

His projects discussed on the episode include Whose Hands Are These?, Sun Not Yellow, and Northern Gloom.

How can I contact The Upside for lessons or recording?

Reach out through The Upside’s Instagram account for current session, lesson, and rehearsal information.

Hear the Full Conversation on the Tone Tailors Podcast

Catch Cory’s conversation with us on YouTube, Spotify, or Apple Podcasts. And don’t miss our separate full tour of The Upside if you want to see the recording rooms and equipment Cory talks about.

Explore music lessons at Tone Tailors and our interview with Adam Stec of Drums Etc., or visit our Lancaster guitar shop for gear and advice.

More Posts From Tone Tailors

Inside Spencer Studios in Lancaster, PA: Recording Secrets, Better Microphones, and Making Music Affordable

Read Now

Inside The Upside: Full Recording Studio Tour in Lancaster, PA

Read Now

Inside a Lancaster Drum Shop: Adam Stec of Drums Etc

Read Now

Win Free Concert Tickets: The Tone Tailors Holiday Concert Giveaway

Read Now

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *