What does a recording studio need to make a great record? A mountain of expensive gear? A perfectly isolated room? An engineer who knows every piece of equipment inside and out? Those things can all play a part, but after touring The Upside, a recording studio in Lancaster, PA, we came away thinking about something a little different: what happens when musicians have a space where they can actually relax, play together, and make something that feels like them.
For this Tone Tailors studio tour, we met up with Cory Paternoster at The Upside to look around the live tracking room, vocal booth, drum collection, control room, rehearsal spaces, and music lesson studios. Cory walked us through the gear and the technical choices, but the bigger story was how the team has turned a place to practice into a flexible resource for Lancaster’s music community.
If you’re a guitarist getting ready to record an EP, a drummer who loves talking mic placement, or a band looking for a room where you can hear each other play, there’s plenty to dig into here.
Meet The Upside: A Lancaster, PA Recording Studio Built Around Musicians
The Upside isn’t trying to be a mysterious, look-but-don’t-touch recording facility. Cory describes the goal as creating a comfortable space where musicians can pick up an instrument, experiment with a sound, and feel at home. It’s a place for recording, but also for rehearsing, learning, and working with other local artists.
The project began around late 2019, when Cory and business partner Brian Doherty needed somewhere to teach and rehearse. At first, they had just one room. Over time, that footprint expanded to include more teaching space, dedicated rehearsal rooms, and the larger recording setup we see on the tour. They were able to use the rooms for practice and virtual teaching during the pandemic, and the space continued developing afterward.
Today, The Upside occupies much of the top floor of its building in Lancaster City. Cory notes that it’s roughly a ten-minute walk from Lancaster’s train station, which has made the space accessible to musicians coming in from Philadelphia as well as bands based closer to home.
The Live Tracking Room: Where a Band Can Sound Like a Band
The first stop is the main live room, and it’s easy to see why Cory is proud of it. The room has enough space for a band to set up together, plus acoustic treatment, a baby grand piano, and a raised stage left over from the days when The Upside hosted shows. That platform isn’t just a visual feature. It gives the engineers another option for positioning drums and trying different microphone setups.
One of the most interesting parts of the tour is Cory’s approach to live band recording. Rather than automatically tracking every instrument separately, The Upside likes to capture musicians playing in the same room whenever it makes sense. They even embrace a bit of microphone bleed when that interaction helps the performance.
That’s worth talking about. In a live session, a drum mic might also pick up some guitar, and a room mic might hear the whole band. In the wrong setting, that can make editing difficult. In the right setting, with players who know their material and microphones placed intentionally, it can also capture the movement and energy that made everyone want to start a band in the first place.
Of course, The Upside has movable isolation options and baffling when a project needs a cleaner separation between instruments. The point isn’t that live recording is always better. It’s that the room gives artists a choice instead of forcing every band into the same process.
Inside the Isolation Booth: Vocals, Amps, and Flexibility
Next up is the isolation booth. Cory shows off a collection of guitars and amplifiers, along with a vocal setup for an upcoming session. The booth has sightlines into the control room, helping vocalists communicate with the engineer while staying in a separate acoustic space.
Even if the band cuts its basic tracks together, there are plenty of reasons to move a vocalist or guitar amp into isolation. A singer might need to focus on phrasing without drums in the room. A guitarist might want a loud amp sound without having that cabinet spill into every microphone on the kit. The tour also shows how The Upside can use the hallway as another place to put an amp when the session calls for even more separation.
For musicians planning their first serious studio session, this is a good reminder that good recording isn’t about choosing between live energy and control. A thoughtful setup can give you some of both.
Vintage Drums, Modern Kits, and Lots of Room to Experiment
As a working drummer and drum instructor, Cory has plenty to say about the studio’s drum collection. The Upside keeps a mix of vintage and modern drums in different shapes and sizes, along with percussion and auxiliary gear. Bands can use the studio’s available equipment or bring in their own kit if that’s the sound they know and love.
Cory and Brian have been experimenting with drum tuning, muffling, and samples. During the tour, Cory mentions getting a Tune-Bot to explore different tuning approaches. None of that is just gear-geek trivia. A snare tuned a little higher, a tom allowed to ring, or a kick drum dampened differently can change the feel of an entire song before anyone reaches for a plug-in.
We’ve had some great conversations about drums and the local music scene ourselves, including our visit with Adam Stec of Drums Etc. on the Tone Tailors Podcast. The takeaway is similar: knowing what an instrument can do is half the fun, and trying different things is how you find the sound that fits.
The Control Room: Microphones, Preamps, Compressors, and a Vintage TASCAM
When we step into The Upside’s control room, we get to the part of the tour that recording enthusiasts will probably want to watch twice. Cory explains that the team has added compressors, worked on the patch bay, and refined the studio setup. Still, their process stays deliberately straightforward.
Instead of relying on an endless chain of processors, they put a lot of attention into microphone selection, placement, and the natural sound of the recording room. The studio has a growing microphone collection, including condensers, tube microphones, dynamics, and older ribbon microphones that Cory says they’ve especially enjoyed using recently.
There is modern equipment on hand, but Cory also points out a vintage TASCAM machine they sometimes use when they want a different, older character. The gear is there to serve the song, not to become the entire story of the session.
That idea lines up with something we explored during our visit to Spencer Studios in Lancaster. Different rooms and engineers have different workflows, but a microphone’s price tag isn’t a substitute for knowing where to place it, how the instrument behaves, and what the artist is actually trying to capture.
Why the Room and Its Acoustic Treatment Matter
One of The Upside’s most important pieces of equipment isn’t plugged into anything. It’s the room itself.
Cory gives credit to Brian Doherty and business partner Nate Williams for building and designing the control room’s diffusion wall. The team has used a reference microphone to measure the room and make adjustments to the listening environment. Cory says those efforts have helped the engineers get their mixes more dialed in.
Acoustic treatment isn’t only about making a studio quieter. In a live room, it helps shape how instruments interact with the space. In a control room, it helps engineers make better decisions about what they’re hearing from the speakers. Treatment, measurement, and thoughtful speaker placement can all make mixing more predictable.
For anyone building a home studio, here’s a useful lesson from the tour: before buying another piece of equipment, take a serious look at the room you’re recording and mixing in. The way a room sounds can change the result of everything you plug into it.
More Than Recording: Rehearsal Rooms and Music Lessons
The Upside’s work doesn’t end when a recording session wraps. The tour also takes us through its teaching area, which includes two drum lesson studios and a waiting space, as well as private rehearsal rooms for bands.
Cory and Brian have taught drums for years, and the lesson program also touches instruments such as guitar and piano. Cory talks about wanting to expand the teaching side so even more local musicians can get started. He also shares how rewarding it’s been to watch some students go on to study recording themselves.
That’s an important part of building a healthy local music scene. A student starts taking lessons, meets other players, joins a band, finds somewhere to rehearse, and eventually records music of their own. Spaces like The Upside help keep that whole process moving.
If you’re looking to build your playing skills, Tone Tailors also offers music lessons in Lancaster, PA, with instructors covering guitar, bass, piano, vocals, and more. There’s more than one way to get started, and the best next step is the one that gets you playing.
A Studio That Welcomes Other Engineers and Different Projects
Another detail that stood out during our conversation: Cory doesn’t want The Upside to operate like a closed-off space that only one person knows how to run. Although he’s the main engineer, the goal is for other capable engineers to get familiar with the room, connect their own computer, and use the studio’s equipment for projects.
That kind of flexibility opens the door to different workflows and different kinds of music. A band might come in to prepare for a big performance. Another might make a rough demo before booking a longer album session. Someone else might want to record a finished project with an engineer who already knows their sound.
Cory also talks about bands that first connected with The Upside through its past live shows and later returned to record. That’s a pretty great example of how a place can support a music community long after the last note of a concert fades out.
Thinking About Recording at The Upside in Lancaster?
If you’re searching for a recording studio in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, The Upside is worth getting to know. Its combination of a spacious live room, isolation options, drum and amplifier collections, control room equipment, rehearsal areas, and teaching spaces gives musicians several ways to use the facility.
Before you book any studio, it’s smart to know what you want to accomplish. Are you recording a full band live or overdubbing instruments one at a time? Are your songs ready, or do you need more rehearsal? Do you have a favorite amp, drum kit, or guitar you want to bring along? Those questions can help you and the engineer make a practical plan for the session.
For information about The Upside, including current services and how to get in touch, visit The Upside on Instagram (@theupsidelancaster). That’s the studio’s main public destination linked here, rather than a separate website.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Upside Recording Studio
Where is The Upside recording studio located?
The Upside is located in Lancaster City, Pennsylvania. During our tour, Cory describes it as roughly a ten-minute walk from the Lancaster train station. Contact the studio through its Instagram account for current directions and visit details.
Does The Upside record full bands live?
Yes. The Upside’s large tracking room is designed to support bands performing together. The studio also has isolation options when individual instruments or vocals need more separation.
Does The Upside offer rehearsal space and music lessons?
Yes. Cory shows private band rehearsal spaces and dedicated lesson rooms during the tour. The teaching program has a strong focus on drums, with other instruments also part of the studio’s educational work.
Can musicians bring their own gear to The Upside?
Cory explains that artists can bring their own drum kit, and the studio also has drums, guitars, amplifiers, and other equipment available for recording. Ask the team about your particular session setup before arriving.
How do I contact The Upside about recording or rehearsing?
Visit @theupsidelancaster on Instagram to connect with the studio and ask about current options, availability, and pricing.
Keep Exploring Lancaster’s Music Scene With Tone Tailors
Our biggest takeaway from this studio tour is simple: The Upside feels like a place built by musicians who understand what other musicians need. There is plenty of interesting equipment, but it’s the room, the flexibility, and the people behind it that make the story worth telling.
We love visiting the studios, shops, rehearsal spaces, and creative businesses that help make Central Pennsylvania’s music scene what it is. At Tone Tailors in Lancaster, PA, we’re here to help musicians get equipped, get inspired, and find the gear that fits the music they want to make. Check out the full studio tour, follow The Upside, and keep supporting the people making music in our own backyard.